I was reading an article in The New York Times this morning that discussed their choices for the top ten ugliest buildings in New York City. Of course Madison Square Garden and the Verizon building made the list. What I didn't know is that the glass acid trip in Astor Place is actually a knock off of another designer's work.Both Ian Schrager and Frank Gehry were involved with earlier incarnations of the project that had hoped to see a hotel on the lot but then 9/11 happened at which point the idea of developing a hotel in lower Manhattan seemed pointless. Gwathmey Siegel & Associates were hired to design the current building, a 14 story residential structure that looks completely foreign to the rest of the neighborhood. The Times pointed out that building was "inspired" by Mies van der Rohe's unbuilt 1922 Glass Skyscraper project, though "the crude quality of its execution is an insult to Mies's memory."
I'm not a fan at all of this new wave of floor to ceiling glass walled building being developed everywhere. Aside from the fact the tenants have no privacy and they are subjected to blinding sunlight all day long, people outside get the lovely view of crooked blinds and cheap furniture. 110 3rd Avenue managed to destroy the Variety Theater so it can subject people passing by to its hideous grandeur.
But Mie's work, aside from being well ahead of its time, possessed the elegance that so many architects fail to grasp in their minimalist designing today.





